PA Antique and Flea Markets

Exploring Black Shutter Antiques in Adams County

A four-photo collage showcasing Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, featuring antique hand tools and garden implements, crowded interior aisles filled with collectibles and furniture, glass display cases of bottles and figurines, and the rustic covered entrance with crates, tools, and vintage décor at the multi-vendor antique store

Black Shutter Antiques in Adams County is the kind of place where curiosity is rewarded the moment you step inside!

A wide interior view of Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, filled with display cases, shelving, barrels, crates, books, toys, and assorted antiques and collectibles arranged throughout the multi-vendor antique store

Located in New Oxford, this sprawling multivendor antique store offers a treasure-hunt experience rather than a quick browse.

A shelf of vintage hardware and industrial items at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, including metal oil cans, oilers, lubricant tins, and workshop tools displayed inside the multi-vendor antique store

Every aisle promises something different, making it a favorite stop for antique lovers and casual explorers alike.

A display of vintage ceramic cookie jars at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, featuring colorful holiday figures, animals, and novelty designs arranged on metal shelving inside the multi-vendor antique store

Directions & Hours

Black Shutter Antiques is located at 4335 York Road, New Oxford, PA 17350.

Store hours are 10 am – 5 pm daily.

The covered entrance of Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, featuring stacked wooden crates, vintage tools, religious statuary, an OPEN flag, and architectural salvage displayed beneath a rustic porch at the multi-vendor antique store

What You’ll See at Black Shutter Antiques

Long, narrow aisles are packed floor to ceiling with antiques, creating a sense that you are wandering through decades of American history.

A long aisle inside Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, lined with shelving and bookcases filled with vintage dishes, tins, toys, containers, tools, and architectural salvage throughout the multi-vendor antique store

Shelving overflows with vintage dishes, glassware, stoneware crocks, and colorful advertising tins from brands tied to everyday life.

Rows of shelving at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, displaying vintage glass jars, bottles, vases, stoneware crocks, and decorative pitchers inside the multi-vendor antique store

Glass display cases showcase smaller collectibles such as bottles, milk bottles, figurines, cookie jars, and novelty pieces.

Glass display cases at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, showcasing vintage bottles, milk bottles, figurines, small collectibles, and decorative items arranged inside the multi-vendor antique store

One corner may feature antique oil lamps, chimneys, and frosted shades, while another highlights scales, tools, and industrial hardware.

Shelving at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, displaying antique oil lamps, glass chimneys, frosted shades, and lamp bases in clear, amber, and white glass inside the multi-vendor antique store

Vintage toys are scattered throughout the store, including farm tractors, Tonka trucks, NASCAR transporters, and classic Matchbox vehicles.

A wooden shelving unit at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, displaying vintage toy trucks, NASCAR transporters, Matchbox vehicles, and collectible advertising items inside the multi-vendor antique store

Furniture ranges from wooden cabinets and curio cases to small tables, chairs, and other accent pieces with visible age and character.

An interior view of Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, showcasing wooden curio cabinets, antique clocks, dressers, and assorted collectibles arranged throughout the multi-vendor antique store

Architectural salvage adds to the eclectic mix, with doors, crates, signs, and rustic materials ready for creative reuse.

A long covered interior walkway at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, filled with vintage cabinets, wooden crates, baskets, doors, signs, tools, and architectural salvage displayed along both sides of the multi-vendor antique store

A dedicated area of antique hand tools and garden implements appeals to collectors interested in craftsmanship and rural history.

A wall display at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, featuring antique hand tools, saws, shovels, rakes, garden implements, and rustic hardware arranged against pegboard inside the multi-vendor antique store

No two vendor spaces feel the same, which keeps the experience fresh as you move from section to section.

A display area at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, featuring wooden shelving with vintage dishes, pretzel tins, kitchenware, small furniture, advertising signs, and a red toy fire truck inside the multi-vendor antique store

The overall effect is delightfully cluttered, inviting visitors to slow down and look closely at every shelf.

Shelving filled with vintage kitchenware at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, including glassware, serving dishes, enamel pots, wooden boxes, and colorful advertising tins displayed throughout the multi-vendor antique store

Final Thoughts

Visiting Black Shutter Antiques feels less like shopping and more like exploring a living archive of objects.

A shelf at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, displaying vintage advertising tins including pretzels, mixed nuts, potato chips, syrup, and cookie containers inside the multi-vendor antique store

Whether you are searching for a specific piece or simply enjoying the eclectic variety, it is easy to spend hours discovering something unexpected.

An interior scene at Black Shutter Antiques in New Oxford, Pennsylvania, showing tables and shelving filled with vintage lamps, glassware, scales, tools, kitchen items, and assorted collectibles throughout the multi-vendor antique store

If antique stores and flea markets are your thing, check out my personally researched guide to 50+ PA antiquing hot spots – no AI-generated nonsense here, just boots on the ground reviews based on my own visits.

A guide to the best antique stores and flea markets in Pennsylvania.

Nearby Attractions

28 Must-See Attractions in Adams County is your guide to more great things to see and do near Collector’s Choice Antiques Gallery.

A collage of scenes from Adams County, PA including the Gettysburg National Military Park, the Round Barn, the World War II American Experience Museum, and the Eastern Museum of Motor Racing.

Discover more than a thousand incredible places to explore across Pennsylvania with the interactive PA Bucket List Travel Map!

Did you enjoy this article?

If so, be sure to like and follow PA Bucket List on Facebook, Instagram, and/or Pinterest to learn more about the best things to see and do in Pennsylvania!

Click on any of the icons below to get connected to PA Bucket List on social media.